jem & walter & shirley

Rilla of Ingleside/ // I LOVE THIS SO MUCH.:

Originally, I was going to write a post ranking all the Montgomery heroes, I’d become acquainted with thus far (I don’t believe I’ve read even half of her books, by the way) but seeing as I’ve already talked about Barney Snaith in my review of The Blue Castle, and I like Gilbert but don’t really fangirl over him, and I dislike Eric from Kilmeny of the Orchard, I decided to focus this post on the Blythe boys.  I was going to talk about Kenneth, too, and the Meredith boys, but this post ended up being ridiculously long, so I gave up that idea.  But I still love them lots.

You know, the nice thing about the Anne series is that you can see the characters you love grow up – and all of Anne’s children are adorable when they’re younger, and wonderful when they grow up.  I’d read Rilla of Ingleside several times before I went back to the previous books in the series (I have read them all, but it was so long ago that I didn’t remember much of any of the books – that is, until I started re-reading them) and it’s delightful to read Rainbow Valley and Anne of Ingleside and see the incidents and escapades and adventures all the children get into.

ALTHOUGH.  Lucy Maud Montgomery wrote Anne of Ingleside (which I’ve read the most recently in prep for this week) several years after Rilla of Ingleside, so there’s a fair bit of foreshadowing that had me tearing up in several places.  And foreshadowing aside, it’s hard to read about all the children playing so happily, going through their little heartbreaks and worries and fears, and knowing that in a few years, they’ll be in the middle of a world war. (AND WALTER AS A CHILD IS SO SWEET AND THEN HE DIIIIIIES.)  There’s one part that comes after Jem has gone through about five dogs, all of whom die or run away or get claimed by their previous owners, and then there’s this:

“Motherest,” he said in a choked voice, “Why wouldn’t Bruno love me when I loved him so much? Am I . . . do you think I am the kind of boy dogs don’t like?”

“No, darling. Remember how Gyp loved you. It was just that Bruno had only so much love to give . . . and he had given it all. There are dogs like that . . . one-man dogs.”

“Anyhow, Bruno and Roddy are happy,” said Jem with grim satisfaction, as he bent over and kissed the top of Mother’s smooth ripply head. “But I’ll never have another dog.”

Anne thought this would pass; he had felt the same when Gyppy died. But it did not. The iron had bitten deeply into Jem’s soul. Dogs were to come and go at Ingleside . . . dogs that belonged just to the family and were nice dogs, whom Jem petted and played with as the others did. But there was to be no “Jem’s dog” until a certain “Little Dog Monday” was to take possession of his heart and love him with a devotion passing Bruno’s love . . . a devotion that was to make history in the Glen. But that was still many a long year away; and a very lonely boy climbed into Jem’s bed that night.



Anyway, now seems as good a time as any to discuss Jem.  I haven’t had the pleasure of re-reading Anne’s House of Dreams, so I don’t have that background information, but it doesn’t really matter. (Though I’ll see about reading it ASAP.)  First of all, his name.  I love how Anne and Gilbert named all their children after important people in their life (not important as in famous, but, you know…) because Jem is named after Captain Jim AND Matthew (that’s his middle name), which I think is lovely.  And he’s awesome as a child – buying that string of pearls for Anne (then finding that they’re fake and resolving to tell her right away), his bad luck with dogs, and that time when he wanted to see the guy getting tattooed and everyone thinks he’s run off.  LMM had a way of writing about children, didn’t she?

Little details in these books, even Rilla of Ingleside, always slip past me, like the fact that Jem was a prisoner-of-war and he ESCAPED.  I want to know the whole story!  Actually, I should probably write some fanfiction.  When he writes to Rilla (I believe it’s Rilla) and says that he’s scared and then he goes MIA and turns up later…that really reminds me of a Combat! episode, actually. (“Mail Call”)  But I digress…  Later on, Jem becomes a doctor like Gilbert later on (that’s one good thing about reading The Blythes Are Quoted – you pick up all this stuff) and he and Faith got married (duh) and THEY NAMED ONE OF THEIR SONS WALTER.  How perfect is that???

And thennnn there’s Walter. *freaks out*  As you may or may not have guessed by now, I love Walter.  No, make that ‘I adore Walter’. (Yes, I over-use italics and all-caps the way fifteen-year-old Rilla tends to do.)  He’s such an amazing character that I can’t help but fangirl over him (although it’s a shame that any character that I love usually dies). 

Now, it’s come to my attention that some people think that Walter’s a coward (how DARE they) just like all so many people do in Anne of Ingleside and Rainbow Valley and Rilla of Ingleside), and I know everyone’s entitled to their opinion, but that’s just wrong, guys.  I wouldn’t call the little boy with the over-active imagination who walked six miles in the dead of night to see his mother one last time before she died a coward.  Would you?  Or the slightly older boy who didn’t want to fight anyone but who soundly trounced a bully for insulting his (Walter’s, that is) mother and Faith Meredith.  Would you?

Walter did not stay for any conqueror’s meed. He sprang over the fence and rushed down the spruce hill to Rainbow Valley. He felt none of the victor’s joy, but he felt a certain calm satisfaction in duty done and honour avenged–mingled with a sickish qualm when he thought of Dan’s gory nose. It had been so ugly, and Walter hated ugliness.

Also, he began to realize that he himself was somewhat sore and battered up. His lip was cut and swollen and one eye felt very strange. In Rainbow Valley he encountered Mr. Meredith, who was coming home from an afternoon call on the Miss Wests. That reverend gentleman looked gravely at him.

“It seems to me that you have been fighting, Walter?”

“Yes, sir,” said Walter, expecting a scolding.

“What was it about?”

“Dan Reese said my mother wrote lies and that that Faith was a pig-girl,” answered Walter bluntly.

“Oh–h! Then you were certainly justified, Walter.”

“Do you think it’s right to fight, sir?” asked Walter curiously.

“Not always–and not often–but sometimes–yes, sometimes,” said John Meredith. “When womenkind are insulted for instance–as in your case. My motto, Walter, is, don’t fight till you’re sure you ought to, and then put every ounce of you into it. In spite of sundry discolorations I infer that you came off best.”

“Yes. I made him take it all back.”

“Very good–very good, indeed. I didn’t think you were such a fighter, Walter.”

“I never fought before–and I didn’t want to right up to the last–and then,” said Walter, determined to make a clean breast of it, “I liked it while I was at it.”

The Rev. John’s eyes twinkled.

“You were–a little frightened–at first?”

“I was a whole lot frightened,” said honest Walter. “But I’m not going to be frightened any more, sir. Being frightened of things is worse than the things themselves.”



And what about the time he ran out into No-Man’s Land to bring out a wounded comrade?  He’s not a coward.  Definitely not. (Anyway, Jem substantiates that when he writes to Rilla and says that, while he’s often scared, Walter never is.)  Walter’s death is one of the saddest character deaths I’ve ever had the dubious privilege of reading about and the letter he writes is GORGEOUS (though the italics sometimes get on my nerves – the last time I read RoI, I read it on my Kindle which doesn’t have the capacity for italics, and I actually liked The Letter better).  By the way, Walter/Una is just about number one of my list of ‘could have been ships’. *sob*

Third, and last of the Blythe boys is Shirley.  He’s the one that Lucy Maud Montgomery never gave a focus/spotlight story to in any of her books, and I so wish she had.  I want to know Shirley just as well as I do Walter and Jem. *sigh*  I think the closest we ever get to any real character stuff on his part is when he enlists and goes off and he’s soooo brave and heroic there so even though I don’t know too much about him, I still think he’s awesome. (Ohhhh and Susan’s reaction to seeing him in his uniform and all that always makes me tear up.)

“So Shirley went—not radiantly, as to a high adventure, like Jem, not in a white flame of sacrifice, like Walter, but in a cool, business-like mood, as of one doing something, rather dirty and disagreeable, that had just got to be done.”

Isn’t he great?

Well, that about wraps it up (and in time, too – the length of this post got away from me about three hundred words ago).  This posts was lots of fun (and very feelsy) to write, and if you’ve made it this far, I salute you.  Thanks soooo much for putting up with all my fangirly comments and verbosity. 🙂

Which Blythe boy is your favorite?  (Or do you favor Kenneth or one of the Meredith boys?)



15 thoughts on “jem & walter & shirley

  1. Nooooooo! You can’t ask that! 😛

    I like them ALL, I really do. Oh, I do wish LMM had written more about Shirley, too!

    P.S. Walter is AMAZING!!!!!!!!!!!!


  2. Ok, so this post made me cry, and I remembered why I love LMM’s writing – it’s so real. Who could not love these three boys? I’m with you on Walter – such a sweetheart. When I read the book, I totally cried for Una and her sweet love for Walter that no one knew about except Rilla who kept her secret. Now I’m crying again just thinking about it.


  3. I think I always liked all Anne’s children about equally. The only shortcoming to Rilla of Ingleside, I think, is that except for Walter and maybe Una and Mary Vance, we don’t get to see nearly as much of the grown-up Blythes and Merediths as I would have liked! It’s sort of natural, of course, since the book is meant to be about Rilla…but after Faith and Jem and Nan and Di and the rest were all such cute, vibrant characters in the two previous books, I’d have liked to have Rilla twice as long and get to see Rilla interacting with all of them, too.

    And one supporting character I wish Montgomery had developed more is Carl Meredith. I always liked him for some reason, and from the very brief glimpses we get of him and his friendship with Rilla in the last book, he seems like he would have been a fun character grown up.

    Oh, and the foreshadowing in Anne of Ingleside! I wonder if Montgomery already had the last book planned, or if she took some of those hints from herself and worked from there? When I was younger and read the book I had no idea what Courcelette or “somewhere in France” meant in that last chapter; it didn’t dawn on me until after I’d read Rilla.


    • The last time I read RoI, I hadn’t read any of the earlier books for quite a while, so I didn’t really care that the other children were in the background. But now I wish they’d all been focused on more. And I agree with you about Carl! I always liked him quite a bit.


  4. I think true bravery is the conquering of fear in doing right, not the absense of fear (I am sure that is a quote although I cannot place it), so that makes Walter a hero unlike some of the blustering bullies and soldiers full of bravado. Walter knew more of what fighting and war would be like than many of the other people. I did not ship Walter and Una, jealousy I suppose, but I do not think that they were “right” for each other like Jem and Faith (you could see that from when they were little) and Kenneth and Rilla. I never was super crazy about Jerry and Nan either. It was like, oh another Blythe Meredith match-up, lets pick the pretty twin (I hate the favoritism and all that ugliness surrounding the twins).


    • Exactly. I know the quote you’re thinking of, but I can’t place it either.

      I never had much opinion on Jerry and Nan, mainly because the last time I read RoI, I hadn’t read any of the earlier books so I didn’t know much about either of them to begin with. But I do get what you mean about the favoritism.


  5. I loooooooooove this post so much . . .

    Gosh, but it’s hard to choose between the Blythe boys, isn’t it? I mean, I LOVE THEM ALL. I think I would have to say that, considered purely as individuals, I love them equally–I don’t have a favorite. But if you asked me which one would I want to marry (if I could), I’d totally pick Shirley. TO-TALL-Y, guys. He’s just so . . . COOL. I love how serious and matter-of-fact he is about everything. “I was eighteen last Monday. Don’t you think it’s time I joined up?” He’s cute. He really is. AND SUSAN LOVES HIM, PEOPLE. If Susan loves him so much, that HAS to mean something, right? I really, really wish LMM had told us more about him. I need to know more.

    That’s not to say I don’t love Jem and Walter too! I do, really I do. I just wouldn’t want to marry either one of them, even if I had a chance. Walter is incredibly amazing, but I don’t think I could take care of him properly. He needs somebody different–somebody like Una Meredith (sob). And Jem–okay, to be honest, he’d be a bit too much of a tease for me to fall in love with. But he’s an AWESOME person and I’m sooooooooooo happy he didn’t get killed. (And don’t even get me started on Dog Monday. Please. I just can’t.)


      • I love the story about how she took care of him when he was a newborn baby, because Anne was so sick. He’s always her “little brown boy”–even after he’s grown up and in the Air Force. It’s just so cute and so sad at the same time. “Jem and Walter were yours but Shirley is mine.” *sniff* At least he comes back safe.


      • YESSSS. It makes me smile and tear up at the same time.

        I’m so glad Shirley came back okay – I think if anyone but Walter had died, it would have ruined the mood/message of the book. Does that make sense?




    I am crushed for life. These boys are my favourite. I love Walter the most BECAUSE BECAUSE BECAUSE AZEFZYGfhehrizuyt’u’tyeruty’ty but I also loooove JEM and SHIRLEY. I love them alllll.

    I’m really not good at writing comments right now. 😛

    ~ Naomi

    PS Seriously though, thank you for this post. It’s amazing. *hugs*


    • SORRY.

      I love them all so much, though, so I knew I’d have to write a post about them this week.

      Walter’s my favorite ALWAYS, but I’m with you about Jem and Shirley. All three of them are amaaaaazing. ❤


  7. I LOVE THIS POST!! It’s lovely and perfect. And nearly made me tear up.
    You’ve reminded me of some details about the boys that I didn’t know so well and made me love them even more-and want to re-read all the books again. 🙂
    Jem is so sweet!! And-he escaped? I don’t quite remember that! You must do a fanfiction of it. 🙂
    Shirley-aww, I love that snippet you included for him. I definitely wish there was more about him in the books.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s